Italian Alpine Polenta with Fontina | Polenta Concia con Fontina
Polenta concia is what the Valle d'Aosta does when corn meets a dairy herd. The verb conciare means to dress, and a polenta conciata has been dressed so generously with mountain cheese and butter that it stops being a side dish and becomes the meal. In the valleys below the Gran Paradiso this is winter food in the most literal sense: coarse yellow cornmeal, a wheel of Fontina from the summer pasture, and the butter that came down with it.
The dish has almost no ingredients, which is exactly why it is difficult. Corn that has not cooked long enough tastes chalky whatever you fold into it. Fontina added while the pot is still boiling breaks, throws its fat and turns the polenta stringy. Butter stirred in all at once disappears, while butter layered in stages stays visible and perfumes each spoonful. What separates a serious polenta concia from corn porridge with cheese on top is patience and the order of operations.
Yield: 6 first course servings or 4 main course servings. Prep: 15 minutes. Cook: 60 minutes. Rest: 2 minutes. Total: about 1 hour 20 minutes. Difficulty: intermediate. Course: primo piatto. Region: Valle d'Aosta.
The Story
Corn reached the Alps late. It came out of the Americas through the Venetian ports in the sixteenth century, moved up the Po valley as a cheap field crop, and only climbed into the Valle d'Aosta in the eighteenth century, where it joined the older porridges of barley, rye and chestnut flour. The Valdostani cooked it in the one pot they owned, the paiolo of hammered copper hung over the hearth, and enriched it with the only fat and protein they had in quantity, the milk of their own cows.
That milk is why the dish exists in this form. Fontina is made in the Valle d'Aosta from the raw whole milk of Valdostana cattle grazing alpine pasture, and it has been made there since at least the fifteenth century. Its fat content and supple young paste make it one of the great melting cheeses of Europe, closer to a raclette than to a hard grating cheese. A summer wheel carried down from the alpeggio fed a family through the cold months, and polenta was what stretched it furthest.
Ingredients
For the polenta
Coarse stone ground yellow cornmeal for polenta, 2 cups (320 g)
Water, 8 cups (1.9 L), plus 1 cup (240 ml) extra hot water as needed
Whole milk, 1 cup (240 ml), optional, replacing an equal amount of the water
Fine sea salt, 2 tsp (10 g), divided
For the cheese and butter
Fontina Valdostana DOP, rind removed, cut in 1/2 inch (1.25 cm) cubes, 12 oz (340 g)
Unsalted butter, cold, cut in small pieces, 8 tbsp (113 g)
Toma di Gressoney or another young alpine toma, grated, 1 oz (30 g), optional
For finishing
Unsalted butter, 1 tbsp (14 g) per bowl, at room temperature
Freshly ground black pepper, to taste
Fine sea salt, a small pinch if the Fontina is mild
Preparation
Bring the water to temperature and salt it
Pour the water, and the milk if you use it, into a heavy pot of 5 to 6 quarts (4.7 to 5.7 L) with a thick base. Bring it to a strong simmer rather than a rolling boil and add 1 1/2 tsp (7.5 g) of the salt. Keep a small saucepan of hot water at the back of the stove throughout, because coarse cornmeal absorbs very different amounts of liquid depending on its grind and its age.
Rain in the cornmeal while whisking
Hold the cornmeal high above the pot and let it fall in a thin steady rain through the fingers of one hand while the other whisks continuously across the whole base. Cornmeal dumped in as a mass forms clumps hydrated outside and dry within. Keep whisking for 2 minutes after the last of it lands, until the liquid thickens and no dry lump remains.
Cook it low and slow for a full hour
Lower the heat until the surface releases a slow thick bubble every few seconds rather than spitting. Swap the whisk for a sturdy wooden spoon and cook uncovered for 45 to 60 minutes, stirring every 2 to 3 minutes and every minute in the last quarter hour, always scraping the bottom and the corners. The toasted sweet corn aroma that defines good polenta only appears after about 40 minutes.
Correct the consistency with hot water
Whenever the polenta becomes too stiff to move smoothly before the grain is tender, add hot water 1/4 cup (60 ml) at a time and stir it in completely before judging again. Work it back to a mixture that falls slowly from a lifted spoon and settles into soft folds. Never add cold liquid, which leaves firm fragments inside an otherwise tender polenta.
Taste the corn before any cheese goes near it
Take a small spoonful, let it cool and taste carefully. Properly cooked polenta is creamy around each particle with a faint sweetness and no chalk and no gritty raw center. If it still tastes of raw flour it needs more time and more hot water. Only now correct the salt, adding the remaining 1/2 tsp (2.5 g) if needed, keeping the base slightly under seasoned because the cheese brings plenty.
Fold in the butter and the first cheese off the heat
Pull the pot off the burner entirely and let it stand 30 seconds. Fold in half the butter, then add two thirds of the Fontina in three separate additions, folding slowly and stopping while soft pockets of cheese are still visible. Residual heat in a heavy pot melts cheese perfectly well, and returning the pot to the flame here is what makes polenta concia turn stringy and release a slick of oil.
Layer the dish and let it settle
Spoon one third of the polenta into a warmed serving dish or into warmed bowls. Scatter over half the remaining Fontina, the grated toma if you use it, and a few pieces of cold butter. Add the rest of the polenta, then finish with the last Fontina and butter. Cover loosely with a lid held ajar for 2 minutes so the cheese softens without trapping condensation.
Finish with butter, pepper and immediate service
Add the room temperature finishing butter to each bowl, grind black pepper over the top and send it out at once. Use a broad spoon so every portion carries both seasoned polenta and molten cheese, digging from the bottom rather than skimming the surface. Polenta concia tightens measurably within 5 minutes and the molten pockets set, so everything else should already be on the table.
Plating
Warm the bowls properly, not just nominally. Cold ceramic pulls enough heat out of the first spoonful to set the Fontina into rubbery threads before the second is lifted. Hold the bowls in a low oven at 175 F (80 C), or fill them with boiling water and dry them at the last moment. This single detail changes the eating experience more than any garnish could.
Finish in the bowl and never before. A knob of room temperature butter on the hot surface, a heavy grind of black pepper, and nothing else. Resist herbs, resist oil, resist anything green for contrast. The visual interest is the yellow of the corn, the pale gold of melting cheese and the sheen of butter. If you want more, put a small dish of grated toma on the table and let the guest add it.
Professional Technique
The controlling technique is the management of starch gelatinisation across a slow hour. Corn starch granules swell in stages, and coarse stone ground meal contains particles of very different sizes that reach that point at different moments. This is why the cook cannot be compressed: the largest particles need close to an hour at a bare simmer to become creamy at the center, and the polenta will look finished on the spoon long before they get there. Thickness is a misleading cue. Tasting for a chalky core is the only reliable one.
The second is the emulsion of cheese into a starch matrix off direct heat. Fontina is a high moisture cheese with a young elastic paste, which is what makes it melt so freely. Above roughly 175 F (80 C) its casein network contracts and squeezes out fat, which is the stringy oily failure everyone has seen. Folding it into polenta that has been off the heat for half a minute keeps the mixture below that threshold, and the starch then acts as a stabiliser, holding the fat in suspension the way pasta water holds butter in a mantecatura.
Texture and Moisture Control
Polenta keeps thickening after you stop cooking it. Starch sets as the temperature drops and the cheese and butter add solids as well as fat. The practical rule is to stop while the polenta is noticeably looser than what you want in the bowl, roughly the point where it falls from a lifted spoon within about 3 seconds. By the time the Fontina is folded in, the dish is layered and it has rested 2 minutes, that same polenta arrives at exactly the right consistency.
Moisture is corrected only with hot liquid, and the choice matters. Hot water is neutral and safest. Hot milk makes the result rounder but softens the corn flavour, so limit it to 1 cup (240 ml) of the total. Never use stock, which pulls the dish somewhere savoury and un Valdostan, and never cream, a modern shortcut that leaves polenta tasting flat and heavy at once. The butter and the Fontina already carry all the fat this dish can take.
Professional Mise en Place
Polenta concia is unforgiving in its last 5 minutes, because the cheese goes in off the heat and the window between correct and set is short. Everything that can be prepared while the corn cooks should be, and the cheese in particular needs time out of the refrigerator.
Equipment and tools
Heavy pot of 5 to 6 quarts (4.7 to 5.7 L) with a thick base, copper or enamelled cast iron
Balloon whisk for the first minutes and a long wooden spoon for the hour that follows
Small saucepan of hot water kept at the back of the stove for consistency corrections
Prepared ahead
Fontina derinded and cut in even 1/2 inch (1.25 cm) cubes, out of the refrigerator 30 minutes
Butter cut small and divided into the portion for folding and the portion for layering
Finishing butter set aside separately at room temperature so it melts rather than chills
Service setup
Pot off the heat and rested 30 seconds before the first cheese goes in
Table fully set and every other dish served before the polenta is layered
Serving dish covered loosely for exactly 2 minutes, never sealed
Chef Tips
Buy cornmeal from somewhere with turnover and look for a coarse stone ground meal that smells sweet in the bag. Corn is an oily grain, and the germ left in by stone grinding is what gives polenta its flavour and also what goes rancid. Meal that has sat on a warm shelf for a year tastes faintly of cardboard, and a long cook concentrates that. Keep what you do not use in the freezer.
If a scorched layer forms on the bottom, stop stirring immediately and do not scrape it in. Transfer the clean polenta above it to a second warm pot with a spatula, leaving the dark crust behind. A single scrape of burnt starch flavours the entire batch with a bitterness that cheese cannot cover, and an hour is wasted.
Taste the Fontina before you build the dish. Wheels vary with the season, and a young winter Fontina is mild while a summer alpeggio wheel aged six months can be markedly saltier. Adjust the final salt accordingly, and if the cheese is very assertive drop it to 10 oz (285 g) and make up the difference with an extra tablespoon of butter.
Leftover polenta concia is a second recipe rather than a failure. Pour it hot into an oiled tray to a depth of about 3/4 inch (2 cm), chill it overnight until firm, cut it into squares and fry them in butter until crisp on both faces. With a slice of Fontina melted on top under the grill this is a genuine Valdostan dish in its own right.
Common Mistakes
Using instant polenta with long cooking quantities. Precooked meal absorbs its water in 5 minutes and then simply sits there. Given 8 cups of liquid and an hour it turns into a thin pasty gruel with no grain definition. If instant meal is all you have, follow its own package ratio and accept a different dish.
Adding the cornmeal too fast. Poured in as a mass it forms clumps hydrated outside and dry within, and those clumps survive the full hour intact. Rain it in from a height with one hand while whisking hard with the other, and keep whisking for 2 minutes after the last of it lands.
Cooking over heat that is too high. A vigorous boil spits scalding polenta, cooks the base faster than the top and scorches the pot long before the grain is tender. You want a slow thick bubble breaking the surface every few seconds and nothing more energetic.
Adding the Fontina while the pot is still on the flame. Direct heat drives the cheese past the point where its proteins contract, and it separates into elastic threads sitting in fat. Take the pot right off the burner, wait 30 seconds and fold the cheese in on residual heat only.
Wine Pairing
Valle d'Aosta Petite Arvine: The most complete white in the valley and the natural partner here. Grown on terraces around Aymavilles, it combines a saline mineral bite with grapefruit and rhubarb aromatics and an acidity sharp enough to cut straight through 8 tbsp of butter.
Valle d'Aosta Prié Blanc: The wine of Morgex and La Salle, from ungrafted vines at 3,600 feet (1,100 m). It is light in alcohol, taut and almost alpine in the way it smells of mountain hay and white flowers. That delicacy is the point: it refreshes without adding a single flavour that would crowd a plate built on two ingredients.
Valle d'Aosta Donnas DOC: Nebbiolo grown at the mouth of the valley near Pont Saint Martin. Altitude keeps it leaner and more perfumed than its Piedmontese relatives, with rose, tar and dried cherry over a fine chalky tannin.
Valle d'Aosta Fumin: An indigenous red that nearly disappeared before Valdostan growers brought it back, dark, peppery and noticeably structured, with black fruit and a smoky note behind it. Choose it when the polenta is made with an older and more assertive summer Fontina, because it has the concentration to stand up to a strong cheese.
Valle d'Aosta Enfer d'Arvier: Grown in a terraced rock amphitheatre so hot in summer that the growers named it the inferno, this Petit Rouge based red is medium bodied, dry and full of alpine herbs and red berry. It sits exactly between the whites and the firmer reds above, with enough grip for the cheese and enough freshness for the corn.
Storage & Reheating
Polenta concia is at its best in the first 5 minutes and it does not hold. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours in a shallow sealed container, spread no deeper than about 1 1/2 inches (4 cm) so it cools quickly, and keep for up to 3 days. It sets completely firm and sliceable, which is normal. Freezing works for up to 1 month but the Fontina loses its smooth melt, so freeze only if you intend to grill it afterwards.
To bring it back as a creamy polenta, cut the cold block into pieces, put it in a saucepan over low heat with 2 to 4 tbsp (30 to 60 ml) of water or whole milk per portion, cover, and let it soften for several minutes before stirring. Work it gently with a spatula, adding liquid in small additions until it flows again, and take it off the heat the moment it is hot throughout. Rushed over high heat the cheese already in the polenta separates a second time and cannot be brought back.
Nutrition
Per serving, based on 6 first course portions:
Calories: 560 kcal
Total Fat: 34 g
Saturated Fat: 21 g
Trans Fat: 0.8 g
Unsaturated Fat: 11 g
Cholesterol: 100 mg
Sodium: 760 mg
Total Carbohydrates: 44 g
Fiber: 4 g
Total Sugars: 2 g
Added Sugars: 0 g
Protein: 19 g
Lactose: 1.1 g
Principal micronutrients: calcium, phosphorus, vitamin A, vitamin B12, riboflavin, zinc, selenium
These figures are estimates. Fat and sodium move considerably with the age of the Fontina and with how much finishing butter each bowl receives, and a looser polenta carries more water and fewer calories per spoonful.
Comments