Italian Piedmont Hazelnut Meringue Cookies | Brût e Bon
Updated: 6 days ago
Brût e Bon is the Piedmontese dialect name of the cookie the rest of Italy calls brutti ma buoni, ugly but good, and the name is a promise rather than an apology. The dough is never piped, never rolled, never cut. It is dropped from two spoons in rough mounds that bake into crags, and the whole appeal of the thing is that no two pieces look alike. What sits inside that rough shell is a very high proportion of toasted hazelnut bound by a small amount of meringue, and the balance is the opposite of what most people assume: the nut is the body of the cookie and the egg white is only the glue.
The step that makes these what they are happens on the stove, not in the oven. Once the toasted hazelnuts are folded into the whipped whites, the whole mass goes into a heavy saucepan and is stirred over very low heat until it thickens, darkens a shade and pulls away from the sides. That cooking drives off water, concentrates the sugar and partly sets the egg white before the cookie is ever shaped. It is the reason the finished piece has a dry, sandy, faintly caramelized crust over an interior that stays chewy, and it is the single thing that separates a real Brût e Bon from a hazelnut meringue.
Everything after that is patience. The mounds go into a low oven for the better part of an hour, long enough to dry the outside thoroughly without pushing the interior past chewy into brittle. They are cooled on the tray, never on a rack, because they are fragile while warm and firm up as the sugar cools. Served with coffee, with a glass of Moscato, or simply left in a tin on a counter, they improve on the second day and they keep for a fortnight.
Yield: about 28 cookies, 14 servings of 2. Prep: 30 minutes. Stovetop drying: 10 to 14 minutes. Bake: 45 to 55 minutes. Cooling: 40 minutes. Total: about 2 hours 15 minutes. Difficulty: intermediate. Course: dessert, petit four or biscuit. Region: Piedmont, the Novarese and the Langhe.
The Story
Two towns claim this cookie and both claims are worth taking seriously. In Piedmont it belongs to Borgomanero, in the province of Novara, where Brutti e Buoni are a recognised local speciality made with hazelnuts and sold by the town's pastry shops as something closer to civic property than a recipe. Across the regional border, on Lake Varese in Lombardy, Gavirate claims the same cookie through the pastry maker Costantino Veniani, whose shop dates from 1878 and whose version is built on almonds rather than hazelnuts. The honest position is that the two places developed the same idea at roughly the same moment out of the same surplus, and that the Piedmontese one is a hazelnut cookie because Piedmont is where the hazelnuts were.
That surplus is the real origin. A nineteenth century pastry kitchen ran on egg yolks. Zabaione, custards, the enriched doughs of festival baking and the pasta made in the same households all consumed yolks and left whites behind in quantity, and whites do not keep. At the same time, the sorting tables of the hazelnut trade produced a steady stream of nuts too small, too broken or too irregular to sell whole. A cookie that uses nothing but whites, sugar and broken nuts, and that is supposed to look misshapen, is not a rustic affectation. It is what a working pastry shop does with the two things it cannot sell and cannot throw away.
The hazelnuts themselves arrived on the hills of the Alta Langa and the Monferrato in force after phylloxera destroyed the vineyards in the late nineteenth century, and the variety that took hold was the Tonda Gentile Trilobata, now protected as Nocciola Piemonte IGP. It is a small, round, thin shelled nut with a high fat content, a skin that slips off cleanly after roasting and an aroma that survives heat better than almost any other cultivar in Europe. Piedmont built an entire confectionery industry on it, from gianduja to torrone to the modern factories around Alba, and Brût e Bon is that industry at its most domestic: the nut, sugar, a few egg whites and nothing else at all.
Ingredients
For the hazelnuts
Raw whole hazelnuts, Nocciola Piemonte IGP if you can get them, 10 1/2 oz (300 g)
For the meringue mass
Egg whites, at room temperature, 5 1/4 oz (150 g), about 4 large whites
Granulated sugar, 8 3/4 oz (250 g)
Fine sea salt, 1 small pinch
Fresh lemon juice, strained, 1 tsp (5 ml)
Pure vanilla extract, 1 tsp (5 ml)
Ground cinnamon, 1/4 tsp (0.5 g), optional and traditional in the Novarese
For the trays
Parchment paper, 2 sheets
Unsalted butter, a very small knob, to anchor the parchment only
On the nuts: buy them raw and in their skins and roast them yourself on the day. Hazelnuts sold ready roasted have usually been sitting in a warm shop for months, and hazelnut oil turns rancid quietly, without any obvious smell in the bag, and then tastes of cardboard in the finished cookie. There is no correction for it once the batch is made, so taste one raw nut and one roasted nut before you commit the whole quantity.
Preparation
Roast and skin the hazelnuts
Heat the oven to 325°F (165°C) and spread the hazelnuts in a single layer on a heavy tray. Roast them for 12 to 15 minutes, shaking the tray once, until the skins have cracked and darkened and the kitchen smells sweet and toasted rather than sharp. Tip them onto a clean kitchen towel, fold it over and rub them firmly for half a minute. Most of the skins will come away. Do not chase the last fragments: a small amount of residual skin adds colour and a pleasant bitterness, while over rubbing breaks the nuts into dust you do not want yet. Let them cool completely, which takes about 20 minutes.
Chop the hazelnuts by hand
Take a large knife and chop the cooled nuts on a board into an uneven mixture: roughly a third left in halves, a third in coarse pieces, a third almost crumbs. Resist the food processor. A processor drives the pieces toward uniform size and, worse, warms the nuts and starts pressing oil out of them, and that free oil is the single most reliable way to collapse an egg white foam. The variation in size is also what gives the baked cookie its crags, so a batch chopped evenly bakes into something visually dull as well as structurally weaker.
Whip the whites to a firm glossy meringue
Wipe the bowl and the whisk with a paper towel moistened with lemon juice, then dry them, and use stainless steel or glass rather than plastic, which holds a film of fat no washing removes. Whip the room temperature whites with the pinch of salt at medium speed until they are an opaque foam with no loose liquid in the bottom of the bowl, add the teaspoon of lemon juice, then begin adding the sugar one spoonful at a time, waiting a few seconds between additions. When all the sugar is in, raise the speed and whip until the meringue is dense, glossy and holds a peak that stands upright. Rub a little between two fingers: it should feel smooth, not gritty.
Fold in the hazelnuts and the flavourings
Add the vanilla and the optional cinnamon and give the machine no more than five seconds. Then take the bowl off the mixer, tip in all the chopped hazelnuts at once and fold with a large silicone spatula, cutting down through the centre and turning the mass over, until no dry pockets of nut remain. Use as few strokes as the job allows. The mixture will look impossibly stiff and overloaded with nuts, and that is correct: the ratio here is roughly two parts nut to one part white by weight, and it is what makes the cookie a nut cookie rather than a meringue with garnish.
Dry the mass in the saucepan
Scrape everything into a heavy bottomed saucepan and set it over the lowest heat your burner will hold. Stir continuously with a heatproof spatula, scraping the base and the corners, for 10 to 14 minutes. The mixture first loosens and looks wetter, then gradually tightens, turns a shade beige and begins to leave a clean film on the base of the pan and to pull away from the sides. That is the endpoint. Never let it bubble or catch: you are evaporating water and partly setting the albumen, not making a caramel, and a scorched patch will flavour the entire batch bitter.
Shape irregular mounds on the trays
Line two trays with parchment, anchoring the corners with a dab of butter so the paper cannot lift. Working while the mass is still warm and pliable, use two teaspoons to drop mounds of about 1 tbsp each, spaced 1 1/2 inches (4 cm) apart. Push the mixture off one spoon with the other and leave whatever shape lands. Do not flatten them, do not smooth them with a wet finger, do not try to make them match. The peaks and loose nut edges are where the crust forms, and a mound patted round bakes into something that looks manufactured and tastes drier.
Bake long at a low temperature
Lower the oven to 285°F (140°C), conventional rather than fan if you have the choice, and bake for 45 to 55 minutes, rotating the trays once at the halfway point. You are drying more than baking. The cookies should firm up and take on a light golden colour at the exposed nut edges while the body stays pale beige, and the surface should feel dry and slightly sandy to a fingertip. If they are colouring quickly at 30 minutes the oven is running hot: drop it by 15°F (8°C) and give them the remaining time rather than pulling them early.
Cool on the tray, not on a rack
Turn the oven off, open the door a hand's width and leave the trays inside for 15 minutes so the temperature falls gradually, then take them out and let the cookies cool on their trays for a further 25 minutes. They are soft and fragile straight from the oven and set as the concentrated sugar in them cools, so moving them early breaks them and cooling them on a wire rack lets the undersides soften in trapped steam. When they lift cleanly off the parchment with no tacky base, they are finished.
Plating
These are not a plated dessert in the restaurant sense and it is a mistake to force them into one. In Borgomanero they are sold loose in paper bags and eaten standing up, and the domestic version of that is a shallow bowl or a flat plate with a dozen piled on it, no doily, no dusting of powdered sugar, nothing arranged. The irregularity is the point and a tidy arrangement works directly against it.
If you want them on a dessert plate at the end of a meal, serve three per person, chosen for different sizes and shapes, set slightly apart on a plain white or dark ceramic plate with a small cup of espresso alongside. A tiny glass of sweet wine on the same plate is more Piedmontese than any garnish would be. Resist the urge to add cream, coulis or chocolate: the cookie has a single sustained hazelnut flavour and a sauce simply covers it.
For a restaurant petit four service, break the largest cookies in half rather than baking miniature ones. The broken face shows the chewy interior and the suspended nuts, which is the most persuasive thing about the recipe and the thing the rough exterior hides. Serve them at room temperature, never chilled, and put them out at the last moment, because in a humid dining room the crust begins to soften within about 20 minutes.
Professional Technique
The defining technique is the stovetop drying, and it is worth understanding why it works rather than treating it as a quirk of the recipe. Whipped egg white is a foam of protein films holding water and air. Heating that foam slowly while stirring does three things at once: it evaporates a large part of the free water, it concentrates the dissolved sugar into a thick syrup around the nuts, and it partially denatures the albumen so the proteins begin to cross link before the cookie is shaped. The result is a mass that holds its own form on the tray with no leavening and no flour, and that bakes into a dry crust with an interior that stays chewy because the sugar in it is too concentrated to crystallise hard.
Continuous stirring is not optional and neither is the low heat. The mass is thick and conducts heat badly, so anything above the lowest setting cooks the layer touching the metal long before the centre moves, and a pan that is left for twenty seconds develops a scorched film that tastes bitter and spreads through the whole batch when you stir it back in. The visual endpoint, a mixture that pulls from the sides and leaves a clean pale film on the base, is far more reliable than the clock, because the water content of the nuts and the humidity of the day both change how long it takes.
The second technical decision is the nut to white ratio and the way the nuts are cut. At roughly two parts nut to one part egg white by weight, the foam is loaded far past the point where it could stay light, which is exactly what is wanted: the whites are structural glue, not aeration. Hand cutting to three different sizes then does the rest of the work. The crumbs dissolve into the mass and carry flavour, the medium pieces give the interior its chew, and the halves sit proud at the surface where they toast a second time in the oven and produce the crags and the darker edges. Uniform machine ground nuts give a cookie that is evenly textured, evenly coloured and considerably less interesting.
Texture and Moisture Control
The target is a two part texture: a dry, slightly sandy crust that gives way under the teeth, and an interior that is chewy and dense with nut. Both come from controlling water, and water leaves this recipe at three separate moments. The roast takes it out of the nuts, the saucepan takes it out of the meringue, and the long low bake takes it out of the shaped surface. Skip or shorten any one of the three and the moisture that remains has to go somewhere, which in practice means a cookie that is tacky underneath and weeps a faint syrup after a day in the tin.
Oven temperature is the lever that sets the balance between crust and centre. At 285°F (140°C) the surface dries faster than heat travels inward, which is precisely the gradient you want. Pushed to 350°F (175°C) the exterior colours and hardens before the inside has dried at all, giving a cookie that is dark, bitter at the nut edges and still wet in the middle. Dropped to 250°F (120°C) the whole piece dries evenly and you get a uniformly brittle biscuit with no chew, which is a perfectly pleasant thing to eat but is not this recipe.
After baking, humidity is the only enemy left. Sugar is hygroscopic and a cookie this rich in it will pull water out of the air on a damp day within an hour, which is why they are cooled in a switching off oven, cooled again on the tray, and then sealed the moment they are properly cold. Seal them while even slightly warm and the trapped steam condenses inside the tin and softens every piece. If a batch does go soft in storage, spread them on a tray and give them 10 minutes at 250°F (120°C), then cool them fully again: the crust comes back almost completely.
Professional Mise en Place
This recipe has one unbroken sequence in the middle of it. From the moment the whites are whipped to the moment the trays go into the oven, the mass cannot be left standing, so everything has to be ready before the mixer starts. Roast and chop the nuts first, line the trays first, and have the saucepan already on the burner.
Equipment and tools
Stand mixer or hand mixer with a whisk, and a stainless steel or glass bowl
Heavy bottomed saucepan, at least 3 quarts (3 litres), for the stovetop drying
Heatproof silicone spatula, large, plus a second one for folding
Two flat heavy baking trays and parchment paper
Large chef knife and a wide chopping board for the nuts
Digital scale, which matters here because the nut to white ratio is the recipe
Prepared ahead
Hazelnuts roasted, skinned and chopped, up to 1 day ahead, kept airtight at room temperature
Egg whites separated and brought to room temperature, at least 1 hour before whipping
Sugar weighed into a small bowl ready to add spoonful by spoonful
Trays lined and the parchment anchored, before the whites are touched
Oven preheated to 325°F (165°C) for the nuts and dropped to 285°F (140°C) for the bake
Service setup
Cookies fully cold and stored airtight, brought out only at the moment of service
Plates or bowls at room temperature, never chilled and never warmed
Espresso or sweet wine poured at the same time, since the cookie is dry by design
A second airtight tin kept sealed so the first can be opened without exposing the batch
Any broken pieces kept aside for petit four service rather than discarded
Chef Tips
Weigh the egg whites rather than counting them. Large eggs vary by a surprising margin and this formula lives or dies on the ratio between nut and white: 20 g too much white and the mass never tightens properly in the pan, 20 g too little and the mounds crumble on the tray instead of holding. A scale costs nothing and removes the only real variable in the recipe.
Make the batch on a dry day if you have the choice. Sugar heavy doughs pick up atmospheric moisture at every stage, and the same recipe that gives a crisp crust in February can give a tacky one in a humid August kitchen. If you have no choice, add 10 minutes to the bake and be more scrupulous than usual about sealing the tin the moment the cookies are cold.
Keep a small bowl of water and a teaspoon beside you while shaping. Dipping the pushing spoon in water every few mounds stops the sticky mass from dragging, which lets you work fast enough that the mixture is still warm when the last mound is dropped. Do not wet the mound itself, only the spoon, and shake the drop off before it touches the mixture.
Taste the mass before it goes into the pan. This is the only point where you can still correct anything. If the hazelnuts taste flat, a second pinch of salt sharpens them; if they taste already slightly dark, leave out the cinnamon, which will push the whole batch toward bitterness. After the saucepan stage the composition is fixed and nothing can be added.
Common Mistakes
Skipping the saucepan stage. This is the mistake that turns the recipe into a different cookie entirely. Shaped and baked straight from the bowl, the mixture spreads on the tray, bakes pale and hollow, and gives a dry hazelnut meringue with none of the chew. The 10 to 14 minutes of stirring over low heat are the recipe, not a preliminary to it.
Grinding the hazelnuts in a processor. The blade warms the nuts and presses oil out of them, and free hazelnut oil deflates whipped whites on contact. It also removes the size variation that gives the cookie its crags and its interior texture. Chop by hand with a large knife and accept the four minutes it takes.
Letting the pan get too hot. Anything above the lowest setting scorches the layer against the metal while the centre is still wet, and the burnt film flavours the whole batch once it is stirred back in. If you smell caramel rather than toasted nut, the heat is already too high. Lift the pan off the burner for thirty seconds and lower the flame.
Flattening or shaping the mounds. Smoothing them with a wet finger or pressing them down produces an even, denser cookie that dries out and looks like something bought. The irregular peaks are structural: they dry first and form the crust that protects the chewy centre.
Baking hot to save time. At 350°F (175°C) the exposed nuts burn and turn bitter, the outside sets hard, and the interior is left undried and tacky. The low oven and the near hour are not caution, they are the only way to get a dry crust and a moist centre at the same time.
Cooling the cookies on a wire rack. Straight from the oven they are soft enough to break and the underside is still releasing steam. On a rack that steam has nowhere to go and the base goes soft. Leave them on the tray until completely cold, then lift them.
Sealing the tin while they are warm. Residual heat becomes condensation inside a closed container, and within a few hours every cookie in the batch has a damp crust. Wait until they are fully at room temperature, then seal immediately, because leaving them uncovered has the opposite problem on a humid day.
Wine Pairing
Moscato d'Asti DOCG: The pairing the cookie grew up with, and still the most convincing. Its low alcohol and gentle frizzante lift scrub the palate clean between bites of something this dense and sugary, while the peach, sage and orange blossom aromatics sit alongside toasted hazelnut without competing for the same register. Crucially it is sweet enough that the cookie does not make it taste sour, which is what happens to any dry wine put against this much concentrated sugar. Serve it properly cold, around 43°F (6°C).
Erbaluce di Caluso DOCG: In its passito form this is the great northern Piedmont answer to a nut biscuit, and it is worth hunting down. Grapes dried for months give a wine of dried apricot, candied citrus peel and a distinct note of walnut and almond, but with an acid spine that most passito wines lack. That acidity is what matters here: it cuts through the fat of 300 g of hazelnuts and stops the pairing turning cloying by the third cookie. The nutty oxidative edge doubles the toasted flavour instead of contrasting with it.
Ramandolo DOCG: A sweet Verduzzo Friulano from the hills above Udine, and an unusual choice that works for a technical reason. Ramandolo is made with a degree of skin contact, so unlike almost any other sweet white it carries a light tannic grip on the finish. That grip meets the drying, slightly sandy crust of the cookie and gives the pairing a structure that pure sweetness cannot. Behind it are honey, dried apricot and a bitter almond note that echoes the darker toasted nut edges.
Vin Santo del Chianti Classico DOC: The classic Tuscan partner for a hard nut biscuit, and the obvious choice for anyone who wants to move outside Piedmont. Years in small sealed barrels under partial oxidation build flavours of dried fig, caramel, roasted nut and orange peel that run directly parallel to the caramelized sugar and toasted hazelnut in the cookie. It is richer and more viscous than the wines above, so pour a small measure and expect it to dominate an espresso if you serve both together.
Storage & Reheating
Once completely cold, store the cookies in an airtight metal tin or a glass jar with a rubber seal, at cool room temperature and away from the stove, the kettle and any window that gets sun. In dry conditions they hold their crust for 12 to 14 days and their flavour actually improves over the first 48 hours as the hazelnut oil distributes through the mass. Layer them loosely with a sheet of parchment between layers, and do not pack them tight, because the crags break against each other.
Never refrigerate them. A refrigerator is both cold and damp, and within a day the crust goes from sandy to leathery and the interior loses its chew. They can be frozen, though it is rarely worth it: sealed in a rigid container with parchment between layers they keep 2 months, and they should be thawed still sealed, at room temperature, for about 3 hours, so that condensation forms on the outside of the container rather than on the cookies.
To bring back a batch that has softened, spread them in one layer on a tray and give them 10 minutes at 250°F (120°C), then leave them on the tray until fully cold before sealing again. This works reliably several times over the life of a batch. What it cannot fix is a batch that was underdried in the first place, which turns gummy rather than crisp in the second bake, so it is worth taking the original bake to the full 55 minutes if you are unsure.
Nutrition
Per serving of 2 cookies, based on a yield of about 28 cookies:
Calories: 210 kcal
Total Fat: 13 g
Saturated Fat: 1 g
Trans Fat: 0 g
Unsaturated Fat: 12 g
Cholesterol: 0 mg
Sodium: 25 mg
Total Carbohydrates: 21 g
Fiber: 2 g
Total Sugars: 18 g
Added Sugars: 18 g
Protein: 4 g
Lactose: 0 g
Principal micronutrients: vitamin E, manganese, copper, magnesium, thiamine, folate
These figures are estimates. Hazelnuts vary in fat content by cultivar and season, and the final values per cookie depend entirely on how large you make the mounds, so a batch of 22 generous cookies will read considerably higher per piece than a batch of 32 small ones. There is no dairy in the recipe, so the lactose figure is genuinely zero, but the cookies contain egg and tree nuts.
Comments