Italian Grilled Beef Rump with Rosemary and Garlic | Scamone di Manzo alla Griglia con Rosmarino e Aglio
Scamone is the cut an Italian butcher reaches for once the loin has been sold. It sits at the top of the hind leg, behind the sirloin and above the round, and it is lean, deeply beefy and considerably cheaper than anything cut off the back. On a grill it repays attention and punishes carelessness in equal measure.
The seasoning is the shortest in Italian cooking: rosemary, garlic, olive oil, coarse salt, pepper. There is no marinade, no sauce, no reduction. What makes the plate is butchery and internal temperature, in that order, and both are easier than they sound once you understand what you are holding.
What follows is how the cut is broken down, why it must be broken down at all, and how to bring it off an ember bed pink, juicy and tender in every slice rather than tender in half of them.
Yield: 4 servings. Prep: 30 minutes. Tempering: 1 hour. Cook: 12 to 16 minutes. Rest: 10 minutes. Total: about 2 hours. Difficulty: intermediate. Course: secondo. Region: central Italy, Tuscany and the Maremma.
The Story
In Italian butchery the hind quarter is read muscle by muscle rather than sawn into steaks, and scamone is the name for the wedge that sits between the end of the loin and the top of the leg. Northern butchers often call it codone, and in parts of Tuscany it arrives on menus with no name at all, simply as tagliata. It is classified as a first category cut, which in Italy means it is fit for fast cooking and for the raw preparations, yet it never acquired the fame of the loin next door to it. That gap between quality and reputation is the whole history of the cut.
The consequence was economic. Because the ribs and the loin carried the prestige and the price, the scamone stayed in the shop: rolled and roasted as roast beef, sliced thin for carpaccio, cubed into a spezzatino when the week was slow, and grilled by the butcher himself for his own lunch. Older Tuscan butchers will tell you plainly that the cut they took home was rarely the one in the window. It is the sort of knowledge that spreads through a trade rather than through cookbooks, which is why the dish is common in Italy and almost unknown outside it. English speaking butchery has no single equivalent name for the piece either, splitting it between rump, top sirloin and sirloin cap, and a cut with three names in one language tends to be ordered by none of them.
The rosemary and garlic belong to the fire rather than to the cut. Across Tuscany and the Maremma, where beef from Chianina cattle is grilled over vine cuttings and oak embers, the seasoning of grilled meat has always been aromatic rather than liquid: a branch of rosemary, a crushed clove, good oil, salt added late. Piedmontese beef gets the same treatment further north. The logic is that a fire already gives smoke and caramelisation, so the only job left for the herb is perfume, and perfume is delivered in oil, not in smoke.
Ingredients
For the beef
Whole beef scamone, rump, untrimmed, 3 lb (1.35 kg)
Coarse sea salt, 2 tsp (12 g)
Freshly ground black pepper, 1 tsp (2 g)
For the rosemary and garlic oil
Extra virgin olive oil, 1/2 cup (120 ml)
Fresh rosemary sprigs, 4
Garlic cloves, peeled and crushed flat, 4
Black peppercorns, cracked, 1 tsp (3 g)
For the grill
Hardwood charcoal or oak and olive wood, about 4 lb (1.8 kg)
Long rosemary branch, for brushing, 1
For finishing
Flaky sea salt, 1 tsp (4 g)
Extra virgin olive oil, 2 tbsp (30 ml)
Lemon, cut into wedges, 1
Freshly ground black pepper, to taste
Ask for the scamone whole and untrimmed, with the fat cap still on. A piece already cut into steaks has been cut across the whole muscle group, which is exactly what this recipe sets out to avoid.
Preparation
Separating the rump along its seams
Set the whole scamone fat side up and look for the pale lines of connective tissue running across the surface. Those seams mark where one muscle ends and the next begins. Push a finger into a seam at the edge, follow it with your fingers rather than the blade, and use the tip of a boning knife only where the tissue refuses to give. The piece will come apart into two large muscles and one or two smaller ones. Keep them separate on the board.
Trimming and cutting the steaks
Trim the silverskin and any thick sheets of fascia off each muscle, leaving a thin layer of the outer fat where it is soft and white. Now find the direction of the fibres on each muscle individually, since they do not agree with each other. Cut each one across its own grain into steaks a good 1 1/2 inches (4 cm) thick. Thinner than that and there is no margin between a seared crust and an overcooked centre.
Infusing the rosemary and garlic oil
Warm the olive oil in a small pan with the rosemary, the crushed garlic and the cracked peppercorns over the lowest heat for 10 minutes. The oil should barely shiver and the garlic must stay blond: the moment it takes colour it turns acrid and carries that bitterness onto the meat. Take the pan off the heat and let the oil stand for 20 minutes, then lift out the garlic and set two sprigs aside for the grill.
Salting and bringing the meat to temperature
Brush the steaks on all sides with the infused oil, grind pepper over them and leave them uncovered on a rack at room temperature for 1 hour. Salt them with the coarse salt only 15 minutes before they go on the fire, so the crystals draw a little surface moisture and then dissolve into it. Meat straight from the refrigerator grills unevenly: the outside overshoots while the centre is still cold.
Setting up the ember bed
Burn the charcoal or wood down until the flames have gone and the coals are covered in grey ash, then rake them into an even bed and set the grate about 4 inches (10 cm) above it. You want steady radiant heat, not fire: a naked flame licking lean beef leaves soot rather than crust. Test the height with your palm, which should tolerate three seconds at grate level, and brush the bars clean.
Grilling to 130°F (54°C)
Lay the steaks on the grate and leave them alone for 4 minutes, then turn them once and give them 4 minutes on the second side. From there go by the probe rather than the clock, pulling each steak when the centre reads 122°F (50°C), since it will climb another 8 degrees while it rests to reach 130°F (54°C). Turn the thicker pieces onto their fat edge for the last minute to render it.
Resting and slicing
Move the steaks to a warm plate, brush them with the reserved rosemary sprig dipped in the infused oil and rest them for 10 minutes without covering them, since a foil tent steams the crust soft. Slice each steak across its grain into strips about 1/3 inch (8 mm) thick, working with a long sharp knife and one clean pass per slice. Season the cut faces with flaky salt at the last moment.
Plating
Warm the plates to about 140°F (60°C). Lean beef loses its appeal faster than marbled beef as it cools, because there is no melted fat to keep the mouth feeling coated, and a cold plate takes a slice of scamone from perfect to grey in under a minute.
Fan the slices in a slight overlap, cut side up, so the pink interior faces the diner rather than the seared crust. Spoon whatever juice has collected on the board back over them: that liquid is seasoned, and pouring it away is throwing away the best sauce the dish has. Finish with flaky salt, a thread of raw olive oil and pepper ground over the top.
A lemon wedge on the side is traditional and useful, since a few drops sharpen the fat on the crust. Serve with grilled bitter greens, white beans dressed in oil, or roast potatoes with rosemary, and send it out immediately.
Professional Technique
The single fact that governs this dish is that the scamone is not one muscle. It is a group of them, the gluteal muscles with a portion of the biceps femoris and the small cap that sits over the hip, and each of those muscles runs its fibres in a different direction. They are held together by sheets of connective tissue, the seams that are visible on the surface of an untrimmed piece. A slice taken straight across the whole rump therefore crosses two or three separate grains in the same cut, and that is the real reason a scamone steak can be tender at one end of the knife and stubbornly stringy two centimetres further along. It is not the age of the animal and it is not the cooking. It is geometry.
The remedy is seam butchery, and it takes five minutes. Separate the piece along its natural fascia rather than through it, pulling with the fingers and using the knife tip only where the tissue holds. Then read each muscle on its own and cut each one across its own fibres, ignoring the direction of the whole piece entirely. Every slice then presents shortened fibres to the tooth, which is the whole mechanism by which a lean cut eats tender.
The second fact is that scamone carries very little intramuscular fat, so it has no insurance against overcooking: past medium the muscle fibres tighten, expel their water and go dry with nothing to disguise it. Take it to 130°F (54°C) and no further, and give it a full rest so the juices redistribute. The garlic and the rosemary are carried in oil precisely because the fire is the wrong place for them. Laid on the coals or pressed against the bars they scorch and turn bitter, and that bitterness clings to lean meat. In oil they perfume it.
Texture and Moisture Control
Two things have to happen at once: a dry seared surface and a centre that stays at 130°F (54°C). The crust comes from the Maillard reaction, which needs a dry surface and radiant heat, so the meat goes onto the grate dry and the salt goes on only 15 minutes ahead. Salted an hour earlier it sits in a film of its own moisture and steams instead of browning.
Inside, the loss is water rather than fat. Muscle fibres contract progressively from about 140°F (60°C) and squeeze out the liquid held between them, which is why the same cut is juicy at medium rare and dry ten degrees later. The rest period matters for the same reason: heat has driven juice towards the centre, and ten minutes lets the pressure equalise so it stays in the meat instead of running onto the board. Slicing early costs several tablespoons of liquid and shows immediately on the plate.
Professional Mise en Place
The fire and the meat both need lead time, and neither can be hurried at the end. Light the coals before you pick up a knife.
Equipment and tools
Boning knife and a long slicing knife, both properly sharp
Instant read probe thermometer, the one tool this dish cannot do without
Charcoal grill with an adjustable grate, plus tongs and a wire brush
Wire rack over a tray for tempering, and a warm serving plate
Prepared ahead
Rosemary and garlic oil, up to 3 days ahead, refrigerated and brought back to room temperature
Scamone separated into muscles and cut into steaks, up to 1 day ahead, on a rack in the refrigerator
Coals lit 40 minutes before service so they have time to ash over
Plates warming, lemon cut, flaky salt and finishing oil within reach of the grill
Service setup
Steaks tempering on the rack, salted 15 minutes before they go on
Probe, tongs and the reserved rosemary brush laid out beside the grill
Resting plate set somewhere warm, never covered with foil
Board and slicing knife clear, since the cut happens at the last second
Chef Tips
Buy the scamone whole even if you are cooking for two. Breaking it down yourself is the entire point of the recipe, and the muscles you do not grill today make first rate roast beef or a fast spezzatino tomorrow.
Keep the trimmed fascia and fat. Rendered slowly in a pan they give a spoonful of beef fat worth more than any oil for roasting the potatoes that go beside this dish.
Use the rosemary branch as a brush rather than a garnish. Dipped in the infused oil and flicked over the resting meat it deposits perfume and a little oil at the same time, and it costs nothing.
If one muscle looks noticeably coarser than the others, and on an older animal one usually does, hold it back. Grill the fine grained pieces and turn the coarse one into a braise, where its connective tissue becomes an advantage.
Common Mistakes
Cutting steaks straight across the whole rump. This is the mistake that ruins the dish before the fire is even lit. One slice crosses several grains at once and eats tender in patches. Separate the muscles first, then cut each across its own fibres.
Taking it past medium. Scamone has almost no intramuscular fat to fall back on, so every degree above 130°F (54°C) shows as dryness. Use a probe and pull the meat at 122°F (50°C) to allow for carryover.
Grilling over flames instead of embers. Flames deposit soot and scorch the surface without heating the centre. Wait until the coals are grey and giving steady radiant heat, which takes about 40 minutes.
Putting the garlic and rosemary straight on the grill. Both burn in seconds at grate temperature and turn bitter, and lean beef carries that bitterness clearly. Infuse them in warm oil and brush it on instead.
Slicing the meat as soon as it comes off. The juices are still under pressure towards the centre and will run onto the board. Ten minutes uncovered fixes it, and covering it with foil softens the crust you just built.
Wine Pairing
Chianti Classico DOCG: The reference pairing, and the one poured wherever this cut is grilled. Sangiovese brings firm but fine grained tannin that meets the seared crust without stripping a lean interior, and its savoury dried herb register runs straight into the rosemary. The acidity lifts the olive oil brushed over the slices.
Carmignano DOCG: A Tuscan red with a small proportion of Cabernet in the blend, which gives it a rounder mid palate than Chianti while keeping the same acid spine. That extra flesh is useful here, because there is no marbling in the meat to soften the tannin, and the faint graphite note flatters the char.
Nebbiolo d'Alba DOC: For anyone who wants aromatic complexity rather than weight. Its tannin is high but silky in texture, its perfume of rose and tar plays against the garlic, and its bright acidity keeps the palate clean through a plate of plain grilled beef. Serve it at around 61°F (16°C).
Etna Rosso DOC: Nerello Mascalese grown on volcanic soil, pale in the glass and far more structured than it looks. The smoky mineral edge echoes the embers, the tannin is moderate enough to leave a lean cut alone, and the red fruit sits behind rather than in front of the meat.
Storage & Reheating
Grilled scamone is at its best the moment it is sliced, and reheating cooked lean beef is close to hopeless: the fibres are already contracted and any further heat only pushes them further. Keep cooked steaks whole and unsliced, wrapped tightly, refrigerated for up to 3 days, and treat them as an ingredient for the next day rather than as leftovers to be warmed through.
Sliced cold and dressed with oil, lemon and pepper they make an excellent salad, and they are very good in a panino with rocket. If you must serve them warm, bring the slices to room temperature first and then give them 60 seconds in a pan with a spoonful of the infused oil, no longer. Raw trimmed muscles freeze well for 3 months, wrapped and labelled; the rosemary oil keeps 3 days refrigerated.
Nutrition
Per serving, based on 4 servings of grilled scamone with the finishing oil:
Calories: 480 kcal
Total Fat: 30 g
Saturated Fat: 9 g
Trans Fat: 0.4 g
Unsaturated Fat: 20 g
Cholesterol: 135 mg
Sodium: 620 mg
Total Carbohydrates: 1 g
Fiber: 0 g
Total Sugars: 0 g
Added Sugars: 0 g
Protein: 48 g
Principal micronutrients: iron, zinc, selenium, vitamin B12, niacin, vitamin B6, phosphorus
These figures are estimates. Most of the infused oil stays on the board rather than on the plate, and the sodium depends entirely on how heavily the cut faces are salted at the end.
Comments